More Proposed Questions for the FAQ

Q: Can a character have more than one of the same type of Treasure?

A: A character may only use 1 Armor, 1 Weapon, and 1 Mount unless card text states otherwise. You can carry more than 1 Weapon, but only 1 may give bonuses or be exhausted (again unless card text states otherwise). The player must state at the beginning of the Quest which Weapon is to be used. Other types of Treasure (such as 2 Wands or 2 Boots) are permitted.


Q: Can I discard a card during a Quest?

A: Not specifically. You cannot discard or buy off a flaw during a Quest, and you may not discard a Treasure. Being able to discard a Treasure would allow you to, for instance, discard exhausted Armor to pick up different, unexhausted Armor. This would circumvent the mechanics of resting, as well as the "1 type of Treasure rule" listed above. Some cards do have text that allow you to discard. For instance, Tax Collector gives you the option to discard a Bag of Gold to pass the Waylay.


Q: Can an exhausted item be used to fulfill Waylay or Quest requirements?

A: Yes. Using the cards in the previous question as an example, if you failed a Waylay and exhausted a Bag of Gold, then came up against Tax Collector, you could pay using the exhausted Bag of Gold. Exhausted cards prevent you from benefitting from card effects listed on the text of the card; the fact that the card is exhausted does not affect your ability to discard the card to fulfill a Waylay or Quest requirement.


Q: If I am forced to re-test or re-roll due to a card effect, does my opponent re-roll as well?

A: For opposed Tests, if the card text says re-roll, only you or your opponent roll (based on the card text); if the card text says re-test, both players roll again. For Trials, which are unopposed, only you re-roll.


Q: What is the difference between a tie and a loss when facing a Waylay?

A: In either case, you may stay to fight again or retreat. The difference is, if you lose, you must exhaust a Merit. You do not have to exhaust a Merit in the case of a tie.


Q: If I failed to defeat a Waylay and there is an Exit Trial to leave the League, do I have to face the Exit Trial to retreat? If I fail that, will I have to face the Waylay again because I stayed on the space?

A: The original answer to this question was only partially correct. The rules describe retreating as: "you may only leave in the direction from which you came", and it happens the next day after a failure. It describes the direction restriction but says nothing about exempting you from Trials. Given that the rules explicitly state you must pass any Terrain Trials before moving, and your only movement allowed is back to the previous League where you came from, Trials should still apply during retreat. The restriction is on direction only, not on the movement mechanics themselves. There is a logical contradiction in the naming...how do you retreat if you don't actually move? If you fail an exit Trial you're stuck in your current League for the day. But if you have an undefeated Waylay in your League, you can only leave by retreating. What happens if you fail the exit Trial (or the other League's enter Trial) while trying to retreat? The most logical resolution is that you stay in the League for the Day, the same as any other failed Trial. You try again the next Day. You would not have to face the Waylay again unless you choose to, because the rules say "If you're defeated by the Waylay Card, you must exhaust one Merit of your choosing. You may try again the next Day or retreat. (On the next Day, you may try again or retreat.)" This means you may choose to challenge the Waylay or retreat, but you may not do both. The original FAQ answer was partially correct in stating that retreating is not actual movement...it is an intention or decision to avoid the Waylay. So the short answer is that yes you must pass enter and leave Trials to move, but if you fail, you do not have to face the Waylay unless you choose to - but not until the next Day, because you already chose to retreat on the current Day when you failed the exit Trial.

Arcadia Unofficial FAQ

I'm putting together an unofficial FAQ to answer questions that aren't in the rules or seem like they might be in a "grey area." These are listed below. If you have comments about what I've put together so far, or have questions you'd like to submit, please enter them in the post comments. I'll post an "Official Unofficial" version of the FAQ in a couple of weeks after enough time has passed to solicit responses. Here's a great chance to get in on contributing to the Arcadia community...take advantage!


Q: When an ability, treasure, etc. provides a bonus to Might, does it also provide a bonus to Combat?

A: Yes and no. A bonus that increases Might also boosts a character's combat results, since characters use Might for Combat Tests. However, if the card that is giving the bonus states that it is for a Might Test, this does not affect Combat, since that is a different Test. For example, a Belt of Troll Strength gives a character +1 Might, which helps during combat. However, when the belt is exhausted, it gives a +3 bonus to a Might Test. It cannot be exhausted for a Combat Test. The card would have to state "exhaust to add 3 to any Might or Combat Test" to give a Combat Test bonus.


Q: Some cards that give bonuses say to use before the roll is made, and some state that it can be made after the roll. Yet other cards don't specify whether it must be used before or after. So which is it?

A: This is simply an inconsistency in card design. By default, a card that states it gives you a bonus doesn't have a condition specified, so it would work before or after the roll (why you would want to apply it before the roll is somewhat baffling). A card that states it must be done before the roll is putting a restriction or condition on its use; it is a gamble whether or not it would actually be needed. So if a card doesn't have this restriction, assume it can be applied after the roll.


Q: How do you "buy off" a Flaw?

A: Each flaw has a bonus point rating associated with it. When spending XP, instead of acquiring a Merit, you pay the bonus point rating of the Flaw and deduct it from your XP. For example, Pansy has a bonus point rating of 1; if you pay 1 XP, you may discard Pansy.


Q: How do I change a Waylay from a Savvy Test to a Combat Test?

A: First, the Waylay must be able to be changed to a Combat Test; if it does not have Combat rating, you cannot change it. Second, you must have a Merit that allows you to change from one Test to another. For example, Bully allows you to change a Savvy Waylay to a Combat Waylay.


Q: What happens if I don't recover a Treasure before I complete the Quest?

A: As long as recovering the Treasure is not a requirement specifically listed on the Quest, there is no penalty for not recovering Treasure. The only downside is that you are not able to use the benefits of the Treasure during the Quest.


Q: I have a Merit that allows me to move two Leagues per turn. How does that work, exactly?

A: In addition to following the conditions on the Merit card, you still must pass any Exit and Entry Trials listed on the Leagues, unless the Merit states otherwise. If you fail an Exit Trial on the first League or an Entry Trial on the second, the extra movement is cancelled and you must stay on the first League. Also, if there is a Waylay on the first League, you may not bypass it and move to the second League unless the Merit states otherwise. Encountering a Waylay on the first League cancels the movement to the second League.


Q: The rules state that a Trial is a special kind of Test. So does a Merit that works on, say, a Might Test also work on a Might Trial?

A: Though a Trial is a special kind of Test, there is a clear distinction in card text between Tests and Trials. If the Merit states it works for Tests, it works only for Tests. The card must state it works for both Tests and Trial to be used for both. For example, Persuasive states "+1 vs. Savvy Trials. Exhaust to retest a Savvy Test." That means you get +1 vs. Savvy Trial but do not get +1 vs. Savvy Tests; it also means you may exhaust Persuasive to retest a Savvy Test, but you may not retest a Savvy Trial. In contrast, the Merit Swamp Rat states "Add 1 to your score against Tests and Trials on Swamp Leagues." That means you get +1 for both Tests and Trials.


Q: Can I move diagonally?

A: The rules state that when moving, you must move into an adjacent League. Therefore you cannot move diagonally unless a card specifically states that you can.